Assess a GEO recommendation through three questions: which platform it applies to, which mechanism it changes and what evidence supports the claim. Without those details, a format useful in one context can be sold as a universal requirement. Entrepreneurs need explainable, verifiable improvements connected to their pages and business objectives.
Google treats optimisation for generative Search experiences as part of SEO and explicitly publishes several myth clarifications. Read them within that platform's scope. A rule about Google Search does not automatically describe every engine, application, agent or internal system using language models.
Myth: llms.txt is mandatory for Google Search
Google documentation states that Search ignores llms.txt. Its presence is therefore not a requirement for visibility in Google's generative features. In an audit, the priority remains checking access, indexing, page information and controls applicable to the intended experience.
A documentation file can have a purpose within a software product or a workflow that explicitly consumes it. Verify that purpose separately. Ask the provider which system reads the file and which documented behaviour follows. A file's existence on a server does not establish its use by all AI platforms.
Checking a recommendation
1
PlatformName the engine or system applying it.
2
MechanismExplain which behaviour changes.
3
EvidenceIdentify documentation and the appropriate check.
A method for evaluating claims, not a ranking algorithm.
Myth: there is special GEO schema
Google does not require special schema for generative Search experiences. Relevant structured data continues to describe actual entities and information according to its documentation. Adding arbitrary properties or commercial claims absent from the page does not complete the business information.
Project evaluation requires the data type used, completed fields and consistency with the visible page. For a product, an incorrect price remains a problem even if the markup is syntactically valid. Technical validation and factual accuracy are distinct checks that should be retained together.

Myth: every text must be split into identical answer blocks
Google states that artificial content chunking or a fixed length is unnecessary for citation in generative features. Readers should be able to follow the idea, conditions and example. An explanation can use paragraphs, a list, a table or a diagram according to the information.
Microsoft recommends clear structure and formats supporting understanding. That recommendation does not establish a universal word count or turn every table into a ranking advantage. An FAQ is useful when it resolves genuine questions. Repeating the same answers across multiple sections adds no information.
Claim, verification, action
| Claim | What to check | Justified action |
|---|---|---|
| “Mandatory file for AI” | Exact platform and documentation | Implement for a confirmed purpose |
| “Special GEO schema” | Data type and its requirements | Actual data matching the page |
| “FAQ means citation” | Genuine questions and useful answers | Complete customer information |
| “X% AI visibility” | Sample, denominator and conditions | Report the metric within its scope |
Myth: allowing training is the same decision as search access
OpenAI documents independent preferences for GPTBot and OAI-SearchBot. Anthropic and Perplexity likewise distinguish the roles of bots described in their documentation. Associate rules with the exact purpose: search discovery, user-requested access or training use, according to the service concerned.
A project cannot reduce these distinctions to “allow all AI”. The administrator identifies the bot, checks the rules and retains controls for private information. When a firewall adjustment is needed, confirm the client's identity through the provider's mechanisms rather than treating a declared User-Agent as sufficient evidence.
Access has different purposes
1
SearchDiscovery and information for answers.
2
Individual requestUser-initiated access.
3
TrainingSeparate preference, depending on the provider.
Configuration starts with the documented bot and purpose.
Myth: one score or prompt describes the entire market
Bing AI Performance has defined coverage and presents citations in included experiences. An external tool may use its own question sample and rules. Before interpretation, request the platforms, languages, countries, frequency, questions and metric definition.
A test directly supplying a business address observes the use of a provided page. A test without the address also involves discovering it. These are different situations. Label results accordingly rather than turning a percentage from a controlled sample into a general share of customers or revenue.
Request an explanation that can be verified
For each recommendation, the provider should identify the observed problem, applicable documentation, proposed change and subsequent check. If many nearly identical pages are proposed, examine their actual usefulness. Google warns about content produced at scale to manipulate rankings or generative answers.
From promise to task
1
FindingWhich page or fact has the problem?
2
InterventionWhich specific change is proposed?
3
VerificationWhat evidence confirms correct execution?
The worksheet supports evaluation without inventing a score shared by every platform.
A GEO optimisation project can be assessed through this worksheet alongside its SEO optimisation foundations. Investment decisions begin with documented mechanisms and business data. New terminology in an offer should translate into specific pages, fields and tasks.
Frequently asked questions
Should every existing llms.txt be removed?
Check its purpose and consuming systems first. Google's clarification concerns ignoring it in Search.
Is structured data still useful?
Yes, for the documented purposes and conditions of the relevant type. It must accurately describe published information.
Are frequently asked questions useless?
An FAQ can help readers understand the offer. Its value comes from the answers rather than the section label.
What should I request for a visibility percentage?
The sample, platforms, period, test conditions and exact definition of the denominator used in the calculation.